Four Treasures Reference Database
Record No. 2337
Confessions of a stonist
Journal Article
Hughes, R.W. (1989) Confessions of a stonist. Gemological Digest, Vol. 2, No. 4, p. 37.
Sinkankas/Born No.: NIS / NIB | RWHL
, gems
In a satirical personal commentary, R.W. Hughes declares his preference for colored gemstones over diamonds and uses this admitted prejudice as the starting point for a critique of diamond marketing, De Beers and apartheid-era South Africa. Although acknowledging the distinctive beauty of diamond, emerald, ruby and sapphire, he finds the stronger colors of the latter three more compelling than the appearance of most diamonds. He questions advertising claims that every diamond is uniquely individual, contrasting such claims with the practical use of identifying numbers engraved on girdles. While conceding the beauty of intensely colored yellow diamonds, he characterizes the colors of many other fancy diamonds as too weak or inconspicuous to engage him. Calling himself a “stonist,” he humorously frames these preferences as a prejudice against particular stones. The discussion then shifts from personal taste to the commercial and political power of De Beers, which he portrays as a monopoly capable of influencing major dealers and producing countries. He argues that monopolistic control maintains artificially high prices, discourages competition and ultimately disadvantages retail buyers. The company’s ability to operate in London is presented as evidence of its political influence, while its position is contrasted with restrictions associated with American antitrust laws. Hughes also challenges contemporary efforts to minimize South Africa’s importance in diamond production, interpreting these claims as attempts to reduce support for possible American sanctions. Citing United States Department of the Interior statistics for 1987, he distinguishes total diamond output from production of gem-quality material: South Africa ranked fifth by total weight but, according to the figures quoted, second in gem-quality production, accounting for approximately 25% by weight, compared with approximately 42% for Botswana. He explicitly states that his purpose is to establish South Africa’s importance as a gem-diamond producer rather than to argue for sanctions. The closing passages turn the language of prejudice against the South African government’s racial classifications and mock corporate assurances concerning political reform. A footnote distinguishes criticism of the government from criticism of South African people, while another targets Optima, the De Beers–Anglo American magazine, for its portrayal of corporate efforts toward majority rule. Humor, exaggeration and wordplay connect the author’s aesthetic preferences with his broader criticism of commercial concentration and institutionalized racial prejudice.
